Canon R5 Mark II Real-World Usability Review
Canon R5 Mk II in-depth user experience compared to Nikon Z8
Welcome to a very different Canon EOS R5 Mark II review, exploring what is it actually like to use this camera in the field.
This is a 100.00% human-written deep analysis focused on usability, ergonomics, customizability and general experience.

I couldn’t find a thorough and thoughtful review focused on what’s it actually like to use the camera (the only thing I actually care about in age of modern cameras), so I decided to write one.
I’m diving deep into camera’s performance in the field and comparing it to its arch rival, Nikon Z8.
I don’t care much about photo quality anymore because we’re way past that with modern cameras; instead I want to know how easily you can access its advanced functions in the heat of the moment and whether there are details that will turn out to be showstoppers (both good and bad).
I believe that when you invest time into researching a camera before you buy it, there should be no surprises once you take it out of the box… yet there always are! Therefore, I won’t be trumpeting the press-release bullet-points, talking about technical advances and skimming the surface of fancy new functions.
Instead, my goal is to go in-depth into stuff you really should know before using it, but which current fast-turnaround press cycle doesn’t really allow for.
I invested a lot of time digging deep into the camera and taking it out to day-long shoot for clients where there are no second chances or room for mistakes, to bring you first-hand impressions of what is it actually like to use. I produced a small mountain of information that I wish I’d had!
Throughout the review, I will also be comparing the two directly competing cameras which, for all intents and purposes, are event-shooters flagship cameras: Canon EOS R5 Mark II vs. Nikon Z8.
(The actual flagships of R1 and Z9 are mostly too heavy, expensive and sports-oriented for 10+ hour event coverage.)
It’s a #longread of 13.500 words, so grab a cup, play some good music and settle in!

Contents
1. Ergonomics
2. Customization
3. Autofocus
4. General
5. Sensor & Shutter
6. Conclusion & Verdict
7. Video


Notes & Disclaimers
Before we begin, here’s some context and important information.
Review is based on R5 Mark II firmware 1.3.0 and Z8 firmware 3.10.
I’ve been shooting film and digital for 25+ years. I paid for all the equipment myself so I can afford the freedom to be completely objective.
I am not a fanboy of any brand — I professionally worked with different major systems: Canon EF (5D Mark III era), then Fuji (X-Pro2 and X-T2), then Nikon F (D850), and again Canon RF (R5), switching back to Nikon Z (Z8).
I bought the R5 Mark II to try it… and switch systems again if I like it more than Z8.
Did I? You’ll have to read on to find out!
Sample photos: All photos in this review were taken with Canon R5 Mark II and RF 35mm f/1.8 IS Macro STM lens, unless otherwise stated.
They are mostly processed in our own style and not raw.
I’m obsessed with user experience and customizability: I cover events with a focus on weddings in a documentary and candid style. I run a lot (literally), use two cameras with prime lenses, usually shoot wide open apertures and mostly with natural light.
I aim to squeeze every last drop of utility from my cameras and customize them to last possible detail to get the shot each and every time, which is why I study and configure them in detail before shooting.
I’m deeply detail oriented, read the 1200+ page manuals first and then scour the internet to answer the rest of my questions. Once I have all this nailed down, I feel the need to share my realizations (and frustrations) which is where this review comes in.
By the end, you should get a very good idea of what’s it actually like to use this camera and a good feeling of whether you’d be able to adapt it to your own personal style of shooting.
If you want a technically focused review with plenty of numbers and specs instead, DPReview does a good job here.
Finally, don’t get misled by all the em-dashes — this review is 100% human written. I’ve been loving the way em-dashes pace sentences decades before AI was a thing; along with the semicolons.

Ergonomics
Gone are the days when the most important thing about a new camera were its technical specifications. Many manufacturers now have good sensors and AF systems, which is why I’m starting this review with arguably the most important topic — what is it like to hold and use the camera? After all, what good is power if you can’t control it, advanced functions if they’re difficult to access?
I tested the Canon R5 Mark II on a demanding whole-day summer island wedding. It was my primary camera from start to end, taking about 4500 photos in total, but I brought a Z8 for a direct comparison whenever the opportunity arose.
BODY AND HANDLING
First thing you notice when looking cameras side-by-side is that R5II is smaller and lighter. While similar in width, Z8 is taller and heftier — with their native 35mm lenses and batteries, Z8 is about 300g (~10 oz) heavier.
This is significant and you’ll notice it immediately, and don’t get me started on the amount of noticing you’ll be doing after 10h on your feet with two cameras!

R5II is compact and feels good in the hand. Since it’s both lighter and smaller, it has less rotational inertia (switching to portrait mode is a breeze compared to Z8) and feels like it’s easier to throw around in a crowd.
However, it’s ever so slightly too small for me personally. I have fairly large hands and the added height of Z8 body does fit me a bit better. The Nikon camera is more stable in the single-hand grip and buttons are slightly more accessible, but this will vary from shooter to shooter.
Both grips are deep and substantial. However, Canon’s rubberized skin for some reason started feeling slightly sticky after a single long shoot (probably from sweaty palms).
I thoroughly cleaned it later with a damp cloth, like I always do with all my cameras (including past Canon cameras), but it didn’t really help. I had Z8 on the same shoot and picked it up regularly, with no issues remaining after cleaning it.
While this won’t influence your photos, it did bother me a bit.

BUTTONS
Canon R5 Mark II has 11 dedicated buttons in the back vs. Z8’s 10 buttons (not including the joysticks). On the top R5II has 4 buttons vs. Z8’s 7 buttons (not including the shutter buttons or power switches).
One of R5II’s top buttons is somewhat useless in my opinion, as it either switches information on the top LCD (press) or illuminates the top display (hold). In practice, this brings the number of useful/customizable controls on the top of Canon down to 3. (Nikon has illumination on the power switch; more details below.)
This difference in number of directly accessible functions is slightly compensated by the default setting for Mfn-button which activates sort of dual function selection screen — you can change two functions simultaneously depending on which control wheel you turn.
Whether that actually compensates for lack of few buttons depends on whether you remap Mfn to another function. (Which you are likely to do; jump to a custom shooting mode is a popular choice because only Mfn allows this if you want a single-press activation. This shortcut is necessary if you want easy workaround for some functions we’ll get to later.)
Since R5II has smaller body, the buttons are slightly more cramped and a bit smaller (approx. 10% less in diameter compared to Z8). The feeling I had using it is that it would fit better into a smaller hand, but that a larger hand would have an easier time reaching all the buttons comfortably. (Especially true for the joystick.)
I disagree with Canon’s menu-button placement (top left) as you need your second hand to reach it. I think buttons related to playback are more suited to this location.
Furthermore, Canon has only one magnifier-button which you need to keep pressing to return back to 100% zoom, while Nikon has both zoom-in and zoom-out buttons, providing quicker access.

I should point out here that all Z8 back buttons (plus top LCD) are illuminated, while R5II’s are not.
R5II has an illumination-button, but the irony is that it’s very small and not easily found in the dark. Even if you find it, it will only illuminate the top LCD which isn’t all that useful — little can be learned from it that is not obvious from main LCD screen in the back.
On the other hand, Z8 has a neat trick if you pull the power switch further in the on direction. It’s a spring-loaded switch which illuminates all buttons in the back and mode/drive/bracket/WB buttons on top along with top LCD. This is useful in the dark, but more importantly, it’s very easy to find in the dark as the on/off switch is placed around the shutter button where your finder falls naturally.
While on the topic, turning camera on and off with Canon R5 Mark II was another source of frustration. Let me first explain why it matters, and then how it underperforms.
Mirrorless cameras eat batteries like nobody’s business. I use a two camera setup for all shoots, so when nothing critical is happening, I’m in the habit of turning the other camera off each time I put it down. By itself, it’s a minor help to battery life, but during a 10-12h shoot it accumulates to a meaningful amount.
Of course, this only works if you can turn camera on very quickly and reliably while you’re picking it up; otherwise you’ll lose shots.
On Z8, power switch is placed around the shutter button, where your index finger naturally falls. So, every time I pick up the camera I turn it on in the same motion, without fail. By the time I bring it up to my eye, it’s fully on.
Not so with R5II.
Power switch is now on the right side; this is much better than before since it can, theoretically, be turned on with just one hand. However, it’s pulled back away from shutter button in such a way that you can barely turn it on with one hand, by distorting your index finger. It’s neither elegant nor comfortable, although it can be done in one motion with a bit of practice.

Another thing is the locking mechanism. I’m not sure what to think about it, so I’ll describe how it works.
The R5II power switch has a middle setting between on and off positions — lock. While a physical lock mechanism is nice, its placement is less ideal.
I realize there were little other options on such a small body. But, for something that might rarely be used (depending on your shooting style), it’s a very prominent position which requires you to switch past it every single time you power cycle the camera.
The other concern is that, if you want the lock to be active, you need to stop mid-way and not go all the way through when turning the camera on. If you’re power-cycling the camera 200 times a day like I am, this is tedious.
What does it lock? It’s customizable and includes: any/all control wheels, joystick, touchscreen and lens control ring.
With Z8 it’s more complicated — it’s done via custom settings/buttons and it’s flexible, but I won’t go further into it. Suffice it to say that it’s not a hardware switch, which isn’t ideal if you’ll be using it a lot.
In my case, locking mechanisms are of little consequence as I never use them in practice, because in the heat of the moment I find it riskier not to be able to access a certain control quickly than activating it accidentally.
I’ll end by saying the best compromise I tried was on D850: a dedicated physical switch around cursor buttons.

TOP LCD
Top LCD screen in both cases is of limited usefulness, with edge going to Nikon. It displays more information on the LCD in default state. What I mean by that is that R5II can switch between two information screens with the short press of illumination button, so while it will display more information cumulatively, you’ll need to work for it.
The biggest difference arises when the cameras are turned off.
Both displays show a tiny bit of information. Canon shows the shooting mode (Av/Tv/Fv/P…), while Nikon shows approximate number of remaining photos on card, populated card slots and target card slots.
This is a matter of personal preference, but since I shoot in Av mode 95% of the time, this isn’t useful information for me. However, having a number of remaining photos along with whether cards are inserted or missing from the camera available at a glance, especially while the cameras are in the bag, can occasionally be useful.

CONTROL DIALS/WHEELS
The R5II’s thumb wheel (officially quick control dial 1) is recessed behind and above * (AE lock) and + (AF point selection) buttons. It’s a bit more awkward to access than Nikon’s thumb wheel which sticks out prominently in the spot where */+ buttons are on R5II.
Large control wheel (officially quick control dial 2) on R5II is a nice touch I always liked on Canon cameras: very natural to reach and great for all sorts of input. Z8 doesn’t have a wheel, but a 8-direction see-saw button which has its good points, but I prefer Canon’s approach, especially for a lot of scrolling through menus or during playback.
Main control wheel on R5II is behind the shutter button (on the top of camera); Z8’s is under the shutter button (on the front).
I’ll talk more about this later, but Nikon’s placement is far better because you can use it while triggering the shutter, without moving your index finder away from the shutter. On Canon this is impossible if you use your index finger to press the shutter button, which you probably do.
AF BUTTONS
AF point selection button on R5II is placed on the back side, top right, near your thumb. It allows you to select size/type of AF area and also activate whole area tracking via info button.
What’s frustrating is that the selection of the AF area/type is only available via the Mfn button, which moves it only in sequential order. This is slow even when you reduce the number of available AF area types. (Directly using the touchscreen is also an option, but it’s slow and awkward while shooting.)
Even after practice, my instinct is still to use any of the control wheels to quickly move laterally between the modes, but no — Canon decided this will actually move the AF area up/down or left/right. Really?!?
Using wheels to move the AF area is among the worst user experiences I’ve seen on a modern camera! I can’t imagine a possible use, except maybe when wearing very fat winter gloves and having all the time in the world.
Even more confusingly, when doing the exact same thing via the Q-menu, the wheel works as expected and offers bidirectional and quick lateral movement. Consistency?
Z8 has a big dedicated AF button on the lower left forward edge of the camera, meant to be activated by the thumb of your supporting hand. Depending on which of the two control wheels you turn, it will either change focusing modes (MF, AF-S, AF-C) or AF area type, which is convenient and straightforward.

JOYSTICKS
Let’s compare perhaps the most critical camera input control — the joystick (multi-controller in Canon’s lingo).
For my particular size of hand, R5II’s joystick is slightly awkwardly placed (above the LCD); my thumb naturally falls on the AF-On button.
Z8’s joystick is right of LCD, and my thumb naturally falls right between the joystick and AF-On button.
This will depend on your hand of course, but on Z8 I need a smaller adjustment to use the joystick which accumulates during a long shoot.
Joystick is also wider on R5II, around 30% by a quick measurement. This is a significant difference, and Canon has a precision problem in the same way that the super thin joystick of Fuji X100VI just doesn’t feel right when quickly moving the AF area. Neither is as physically precise as the Z8’s in practice.
Finally, Canon’s interpretation of your input is somewhat lacking, making AF area movement less predictable that it should be. It’s not about the speed of the movement, which is customizable in 3 steps, but the acceleration which feels non-linear, hence less predictable.
I realize the basic idea: if you keep moving the AF area, accelerating the movement eventually should help you span a larger distance and reach your target more quickly. It’s the same idea behind focus-by-wire lens rings and mouse cursor acceleration. However, for critically precise movement this acceleration actually hinders precision because it decreases predictability.
Despite hours of practice, I kept having precision issues moving the R5II’s AF area as I’d often overshoot the target due to acceleration. I tried to adapt by releasing the joystick sooner, but then I’d often undershoot. So sometimes I’d need several iterations before I hit the target, which in event photography means wasting precious time.
This was especially pronounced while recording video, because shooting handheld you’re trying to keep the joystick movements gentle and I felt like I was wrestling with it a bit.
My guess is that much more practice would help; how much, is difficult to tell.
Nikon’s joystick feels more linear and predictable. I’m sure this isn’t a realistic number, but using Z8’s joystick subjectively felt 2x faster, in a way that every millisecond feels like an eternity when you’re watching moment disappearing before your eyes while waiting for your camera.
Don’t get me wrong; R5II’s joystick is still perfectly usable, but when you’re on the knife’s edge of capturing real-time events with no do-overs, I tend to be very nit-picky about anything that adds or shaves off even milliseconds.

MAIN LCD DESIGN
R5II has a fully articulated flip-out screen, while Z8 has a two-axis tilting LCD (horizontally and vertically).
On paper, fully articulated LCD is better, giving you more flexibility: you can shoot above your head with a perfect perpendicular view of the screen, you can turn it forward for self-portrait or let a subject you’re video recording see themselves. You can close it with screen inside for protection.
All great options.
The trouble is that a flip-out screen needs to stick out very far from the camera body in order to have any kind of articulation, and in order to switch from regular (flush with camera body) mode to articulated mode takes a lot of time.
For example, when I want to shoot overhead, I need about 2 seconds to tilt Z8’s LCD with left hand while raising the camera (even less if I pulled the screen slightly ajar in expectation). It’s easy and smooth to switch between normal and overhead shooting positions.
With R5II I need closer to 5 seconds to flip out the LCD, rotate it and raise the camera. It’s super-frustrating to do it often.
Why not leave it flipped out and just change the tilt when needed? I’m glad you asked.
It sticks far away from the camera, almost doubling the camera’s effective width and getting into the way.
Not only that — it’s fragile! When working with two cameras I just can’t lower the camera into the resting position and grab the other camera with screen still flipped out; it wouldn’t last long without breaking off.
I shoot video handheld with a camera strap mounted for a three point support, which makes for an even worse scenario. Screen can tangle with the strap, and even if it doesn’t, camera strap goes right over the screen partially obscuring it.
This kind of flip-out screen is a nightmare for two-camera setup in photography and for run-and-gun handheld videography. For me personally, this is an actual dealbreaker.

EVF DESIGN
Canon has a very shielded and protruding EVF with generous rubber padding on its end, possibly because of it’s eye control function which may need this additional shield. R5II’s EVF sticks around 20mm (0.8″) from the back of the camera, while Z8 is around 10mm (0.4″).
R5II’s EVF is enjoyable to use as it effectively reduces stray rays of sun in your eyes and you’ll never stick your sweaty face into the rear LCD as it keeps you further way, but it’s also slightly more difficult to fit into a tight bag. (To be fair, you could also say this for Nikon’s bigger body.)
More on EVF quality in general photography section.
CARDS & BATTERIES
Let’s talk about cards and batteries… and nitpick a bit.
Nikon’s two cards are laterally offset, which makes them easier to quickly insert in the dark — SD card is less prone to falling into the fat CFExpress slot because you tend to insert it lower down. With Canon they as right next to each other and you really need to see what you’re doing.
Nikon uses push to insert/eject for both cards, while Canon has an eject button for the CFE card.
One issue that irritates me is Canon’s approach to card and battery doors.
If they’re open, camera will instantly turn off (or not turn on) regardless of card/battery status. While this theoretically could serve as a warning that you have an open door, my worry is that if something were to happen to one of those doors in the field, camera would be rendered useless!
This isn’t just a theoretical problem; a decade ago I had an accident where my 5D Mark III camera fell to the marble floor. It was fine, but the battery door were damaged and wouldn’t close. Now you have a camera unable to shoot unless you keep the door shut tightly with your right hand, going dead as soon as you release the pressure.
I just can’t understand this approach. (Z8 works normally with doors closed, open or missing.)
One tiny detail I liked is Canon’s ability to display the percentage of available card space instead of approximate number of photos left, along with ability to show total size of occupied card space (in the format card menu).

Customization
Now we’re coming to the crux of the matter. Camera manufacturers can’t please everyone by default, so they need to give us wide enough of a latitude to adapt the cameras to our preference without overwhelming us with hundreds of options.
Generally, both R5II and Z8 offer a lot of options for customization. And I mean a lot; they have several layers: customizable physical buttons, Q-menu items, My Menu items, custom shooting modes and then the deeper custom functions in the menus.
Canon offers more options which you can attach to custom buttons. Yes, you will feel choice paralysis and take ages to find the functions you’re looking for, but investing time here pays later.
Listing options which are (not) available in each camera would be overwhelming (see R5II user’s guide p1060 for a full list), so I’ll conclude this part by saying that the fewer options available on Nikon pretty much still fulfil real world needs for my type of shooting.
GATEWAY TO SUPERPOWERS ⚡️
Both cameras have a powerful trick that is easy to miss, so let’s dedicate a bit of time to it.
While each supports many functions you can map directly to custom buttons, they are still limited in number. You can easily need something that’s just not supported, often due to manufacturer’s unknowable idiosyncracies beyond our mortal understanding. (I could make a whole list of largely useless functions that are available, and a few useful ones which aren’t.)
However, both cameras have a tiny gateway into a whole another dimension of customizability that’s easy to glance over.
The basic idea is that there is one physical button that will instantly recall or quickly switch into a custom shooting mode, where you can pre-configure a very wide array of parameters, especially those not available for direct mapping to buttons.
The practical aspects of this differ between these two systems.
With Canon, you can use (exclusively) Mfn button to jump between custom C1/C2/C3 modes sequentially, or the SET button to pop-up a choice between three custom modes selectable via command wheels.
So, you can setup any of the C-modes to your liking and activate it pretty quickly.
With Nikon it’s slightly more obscure and complicated, but also more powerful.
The setting you’re looking for is called recall shooting functions (RSF) and it’s assignable to wide range of buttons (including buttons on the Z-series lenses). It’s not just one or two buttons as on R5II.

When setting up, you can recall any or all of the following: shooting mode, metering, the entire exposure triangle, exposure compensation, WB, complete AF settings and shutter release mode.
You can also choose activation type: toggle-hold or only-while-depressed.
In practice this means you have a whole another shooting setup available at a quick press of a single button.
Sounds great, right? It is. But there are some limitations, so let’s talk about them.
Toggle-hold in Nikon is active only before the standby timer expires, or until you turn off the camera. So, Canon is a bit slower to activate the C-mode, but it’s persistent once you’re in it. Nikon is better for a quick and temporary jump.
Canon is less generally flexible here because it’s not a quick single press of a button. Mfn comes closest as it sequentially switches between the C-modes without additional input (as required when using SET button).
Workaround to speed things up is to use just a single C-mode and deactivate the rest in settings, so pressing Mfn will instantly make the switch.
Of course, with Canon you thereby occupy C-modes for whatever scenario(s) you predetermined and can’t use them for anything else.
Nikon Z8 has 4 available modes (denoted with A, B, C and D; you can also assign a description to each one in the menu). But, they are the only modes you have at your disposal.
You assign P/A/S/M exposure control mode to each one, while with Canon R5II the C1/C2/C3 modes are in addition to usual Av/Tv/Fv/P etc.
Canon gives you more modes to work with in total.
Nikon’s recall shooting functions has another issue — it’s just one set of settings in a given mode. If you assign RSF to two buttons thinking you’ll get two sets of settings, you won’t. It will just be the last set of settings you’ve set up in the current mode, activated with either button.
Workaround here is to use different shooting modes to set up RSF, as each one will save its own version of settings. You will still need to switch between modes (I’m using Fn3 + dial), so there’s an extra step.
Both cameras have a world of options buried inside these functions and they’re great when you want to quickly switch shooting scenarios while keeping the option of quickly jumping back.

THE UNASSIGNABLE
Some menu items just can’t be mapped to a direct access, or it doesn’t make sense to do so. But there’s a workaround for this as well.
Nikon has an option of allowing you to map a custom button to directly open (and activate) first item in the My Menu, whichever one you’ve decided to put there. This effectively allows you to directly access any imaginable function and display it on your screen.
Canon comes close — it can take you to My Menu directly, but stops short of activating the item so you need one more button press.
SETS OF SETTINGS
R5 Mark II offers you to save all camera settings into 10 slots on the memory card, with custom names (either to load when needed, or to transfer to a new camera). Z8 offers only one slot, so you’d need a workaround to use multiple settings loaded from files (e.g. use multiple cards, or store them on the computer and transfer to card when needed).
Q-MENU
Q-menus and My Menus have different structures on either camera.
Canon’s Q-menu is split into two columns of five items, on either side of the screen. Nikon’s i-menu is shown in two rows of five items near bottom of the screen.
I find Nikon’s organization slightly clearer for quick overview, but Canon has advantage that if you’re not using all 10 items (and I’m not), it won’t display those which you didn’t set up. This means you can move between them faster. Nikon always displays 10 items, whatever they are.
It’s easier to see the highlighted option on Nikon (yellow background) than Canon (orange outline). However, Canon will immediately display all available options of the selected function at the bottom of the screen, reducing guesswork.
Nikon will display those options above the i-menu icons, but only once you start changing them via control wheels.
Unless you know what you’re doing, Canon is easier to understand.
A small frustration here is that neither camera allows you to go into a proper menu for a function you’re adjusting, where you could reach additional options. For example, pressing OK to go into a menu and using shutter half-press to leave the Q-menu would work just fine. Yes, it might confuse some people at first, but this isn’t a consumer camera.

GENERAL CUSTOMIZATION
Both cameras offer options to limit selectable modes of shooting, AF modes, AF areas etc., but Canon even offers limiting range of available apertures, shutter speeds and ISOs! (Nikon allows limiting the ISO range.)
I’m not exactly sure how often I’d need that, but I guess it’s good to have the option?
One thing that needs to be mentioned here is that Canon allows customizing exposure level increments between 1/2 and 1/3EV (for ISO it’s 1/3 or 1EV). Nikon allows for 1/3, 1/2 or 1EV step for general exposure control.
Seemingly a small oversight on Canon’s behalf, the lack of 1EV-step setting disproportionately affected my quick documentary approach.
The issue is twofold: lack of a 1EV step for controlling the aperture, exacerbated by the default placement of aperture control wheel in Av mode.
(Aperture control can be moved to another wheel or lens ring, so I’ll focus on the 1EV step issue.)
When I have sufficiently fast shutter speeds available, I generally don’t use aperture to control the amount of light hitting the sensor because I care about depth-of-field a lot.
This means I don’t ever need small aperture adjustments (1/3 or 1/2 EV) because they’re not noticeable in the photo. When I want to switch between shallow and deep DOF, I do large aperture adjustments of several EVs and if I need to do this quickly, 1EV step is crucial. Using a smaller EV-steps means more turning and clicking the wheel, which wastes precious time.
Case in point — we love wide open aperture and we mostly shoot wide open, but sometimes you just can’t get away with it when shooting multiple people.
Still, we’re often willing to risk it for posed shots, so that a group of people who were in a perfect line will still get that nice blurry background. On the other hand, it would be irresponsible to risk not having all faces in proper focus because of wide open aperture.
How we solve this in a run-and-gun scenario when you don’t have more than a few seconds to shoot is by first shooting stopped down and, while we still shoot, open up the aperture. This needs to be quick as we can’t keep people for too long, so it’s crucial that aperture adjustment is quick.
Z8 set to 1EV adjustments and control wheel under my middle finger (while using index for shutter) allows me to shoot and adjust the aperture simultaneously, which makes the whole process invisible and painless.
R5II unfortunately doesn’t allow for large aperture adjustments, so even set to 1/2EV still needs double the amount of clicking the wheel (and double the time) compared to Z8 to reach same aperture. And if you don’t want to switch wheel functions for whatever reason, you’ll also be unable to to shoot and adjust aperture simultaneously, because of main dial position which is behind the shutter button (not in front and below as on Z8).
This means added friction when you need quick aperture adjustments.
Now, we could discuss how to rearrange dial functions to alleviate this issue, but I’ll still be twice slower on R5II. (And re-learn new dial functions.)

MY MENU
My Menu helps with anything that manufactures didn’t allow us to put in the Q-menu. Both cameras have it — it’s a custom menu which you populate with options you frequently access. Again, it’s structured differently. Z8 has only one menu tab where you add options and scroll down if necessary. Canon limits you to 6 items (7th is always the configure option), but it allows multiple tabs.
Both works well, but I prefer Nikon’s approach for two reasons.
First, as my needs change and I add or remove functions, it’s very quick to re-sort them as you desire when they’re all in the same list. With Canon you need to delete them off one list and add to another, which is tedious since the list of available options is excruciatingly long and apparently disorganized.
With Canon, it’s just one long, endless, confusing list (they’re basically all functions from menus dumped sequentially, so you can guess roughly in which part of the list you’ll find what you want if you know the menu where it lives, but it’s still an immensely long list). So yes, you’ll find your option… eventually.
Nikon groups functions as they’re grouped in the main menu, which means they’re easier to find. It also denotes already included items with a checkmark, so if you’re adding a few related functions, it’s even easier to quickly scroll to find them and work from there.
Secondly, each Canon’s tab ends with configure option (pertaining just to that one tab), which is logical but also inefficient. In my case I needed 4 tabs to keep all my functions, while in reality I’d only need 3 tabs if each of them didn’t contain the configure option. Since the last tab is always the configuration tab (options pertaining to My Menu tabs), it would be more efficient if the configure option was there and upon entering it, you pick which tab you want to adjust.
Grouping types of items which belong together into different tabs is useful, but would be even more so if I could add more than 6 items to one tab. Yes, I’d then need to scroll vertically, but then a related 7th or 8th function could be in the group where it belongs.
Currently it must be moved to a new tab with other random functions because it didn’t fit on the tab where it would logically belong, often just because the 7th row is always occupied by the configure setting.

MENUS
More generally, I find Nikon’s menu structure to be slightly more efficient. The issue is that Canon avoids vertical menu scrolling at all costs.
We could discuss the sense in that, but the fact remains that when sub-grouping menu items by some logic, they will leave some submenus partially empty (as there aren’t enough topically-linked items, or just a few items overflowed to the next tab), thereby increasing the amount of horizontal scrolling you need to do while digging through the menus.
In practice that means more fragmentation in the menus than necessary and exclusively horizontal scrolling which I’d venture to judge is somewhat unnatural, given that on our computers and phones we mostly scroll vertically.
To be fair, with three dials which do different kinds of scrolling, once you learn the menus and wheels on Canon, you will probably be quicker than doing an ordinary vertical scroll through Nikon’s longer menu.
Whether all that matters in practice is another question — in the end most important functions will either end up being mapped to direct buttons, Q-menu or My Menu.
BURST RATE CUSTOMIZATION
Even though R5 Mark II can be customized beyond recognition, one area I find it a bit lacking is the burst rate customization. You can adjust the burst rate only when using the electronic shutter. I’m not sure whether this is a technical limitation or not?
On Z8 it’s customizable to a high degree and very easily, without digging through the menus: when setting the drive mode via direct button, option is under the front wheel (back wheel switches between drive modes).
Good thing is that both cameras can map a custom button for a temporary jump to different drive mode. In R5II it’s a straightforward setting; with Z8 it’s done via recall shooting mode function.
I also love that both cameras can quickly jump into crop-mode (I like to map this on movie record button as it’s very easy to activate while shooting). When shooting primes, this is a god-send and both cameras have enough megapixels that there’s still plenty left after the crop.

Autofocus
AF MODES
When you switch between systems with some regularity you start noticing idiosyncrasies within them which you may otherwise easily overlook. Case in point: AF mode nomenclature in the Canon system.
Here it is: one shot, AI focus, photo servo AF, movie servo AF, whole area tracking.
I should explain here, because this overlap may be confusing, that photo servo AF and movie servo AF are two different things. One is continuous AF on demand (in photo mode), while the other is constant AF without user input (in movie mode).
Is it just me, or is this unnecessarily obscure? Once you get used to it, sure, it’s fine. But to a new user?
For comparison, Nikon uses: AF-S (single), AF-C (continuous), AF-F (full-time), 3D-tracking.
So, Canon has one more photo AF mode: AI focus. What does it do? Camera intelligently decides whether you need single AF or continuous AF and constantly adapts as you go.
I’ll be honest and admit I didn’t spend too much time testing it. Maybe for absolute beginners (willing to spend $4000 on this camera?) it may make certain sense, but to everyone else, I’d venture a guess you’ll want to pick the focusing mode yourselves.
More generally, I almost can’t remember using the AF-single on a modern mirrorless body. Focus-and-recompose has been dead ever since we got (almost) whole sensor area covered with focus points, so I always opt for continuous AF — subjects move and I move, so it can hardly hurt. (OK, I don’t shoot landscapes, obviously.)
Both cameras have a lot of focus points throughout the sensor area; Nikon had hundreds, Canon has thousands because of its dual-pixel structure of sensor. In practice I couldn’t tell any difference and was much more focused on the fact I was often wrestling with R5II’s joystick (as described in ergonomics section).

AF AREAS
Now that we dealt with AF focusing modes, let’s talk about AF areas. Nikon uses basic structure of a rectangular AF area and you choose its size and shape. Straightforward enough.
Canon has much more options, and then some of those options are duplicated in the menu, but with a padlock icon over them. We’ll get to that.
To start, Canon R5 Mark II has all the areas and shape customization Nikon Z8 offers. But then it has simulated AF-expansion areas reminiscent of (D)SLR-era. For example, you have a square AF area expanded with smaller squares in cross-pattern around it, or one completely surrounded by smaller AF areas.
Historical Perspective
The basic idea is that if your subject leaves the main AF area, one of surrounding smaller AF squares will pick it up.
This made a lot of sense in the DSLR-era where we were limited to a comparatively small number of small AF points on the dedicated sensor. Each point (representing a tiny individual sensor below the mirror) was very small compared to today’s AF areas.
Keeping a single small point exactly on a quickly moving target was no easy task, which is why we got groups of AF points creating something like an “AF area” (emphasis on those quotes since it wasn’t an area, but a collection of adjacent points with some space in between).
So, while the central point was always given precedence, surrounding ones were used when camera judged it was warranted to do so.
So with all that in mind, I’m posing the question of necessity in offering the same principle now that we have an arbitrarily large AF area available? (itself easily covering whole DSLR’s expanded area)
This is even more mysterious because both cameras allow for subject detection some small distance outside of active AF area, which means the AF area is already acting as if it was (invisibly) expanded!
As a curiosity, with some cameras like Fujis, this small distance for subject detection is actually huge, 2.5x the size of active AF area.
Anyway, in my testing of R5II, I was mostly using the expand AF area: cross to see if it worked differently in some way. (The other, larger area is named expand AF area: around).
I didn’t really notice any impact to AF performance compared to 1-point AF area, but maybe my use-case wasn’t a good use for these expanded areas. Perhaps the idea is that fast and unpredictable objects warrant larger AF area, but instead of just using that larger area, you want to tell the camera to keep emphasis on the center; and if it thinks it’s warranted, go even further outside than it usually would?
Okay, so I mentioned that certain AF areas are duplicated in the AF menu, but with a padlock icon over them. This confused me initially, but I soon found out that this means that subject detection is turned off in these modes.
I’m not sure what to think about it. My instinct would be to map subject detection to a custom key, giving me instant access, but I guess this works too if you have enough time to switch AF modes quickly (whether you actually do is discussed in the ergonomics section). You can turn off AF areas you don’t want in both cameras, so they won’t get into your way.


⇡ Used right, Canon R5 Mark II has nearly flawless AF performance
AUTOFOCUS PERFORMANCE
After reviewing several thousand photos I took on the wedding in all kinds of conditions, practically all photos are in perfect or usable focus. It’s a rare photo that’s slightly out of focus. In short, R5II’s AF performance is quick and precise.
I’m impressed.
When light levels get really really dim, Canon has a slight edge over Z8; Canon put all those dual-pixels to good use.
But in almost all realistic conditions, both cameras have stunningly good AF which will spoil you, so I won’t spend more time on it.
FACE DETECTION
What I’m more interested in is face detection, as there is still space some for improvement, slight as it may be.
(Note: I didn’t test other subject detection modes – animals and vehicles – and they were turned off throughout testing.)
Initial tests straight out of the box suggested R5II had better face detection when it came to small faces. It was a silly test, but I just pointed both cameras to series of portraits of differing sizes on my wall. When the faces were tiny in the viewfinder, Canon could detect many faces even in various rotations; Z8 could detect almost none.
It’s an extreme case and arguably not that useful, but I was curious. Based on this, my expectations were that in practice Canon would wipe the floor with Nikon. After all, it had an extra year of development to improve face detection, it has an AI co-processor Nikon doesn’t and we all know how fast AI moves these days. It was only to be expected.
My next test was to haunt my kids with both cameras as they slept in darkness. I decided to try subject tracking along with face detection. Due to darkness, this time I was very close to their faces, but they had their eyes closed. R5II was pretty good — it had good detection and reasonable tracking in these extreme conditions.
Z8 did not detect the face, nor track it to R5II’s degree once I initiated object-tracking (since subject wasn’t detected).
If we ignore subject detection, the focusing speed in the dark was comparable on both cameras, slight edge going to Canon.

At this point, day 1, I was very impressed with R5II.
However, the next day I started seeing the flip side of the coin.
There is a price to be paid for super-keen face detection: false positives.
While I was testing AF around the studio, I pointed the camera towards a cup which R5II detected as a face. Later, a vase with some LEGO flowers and plants around it confused it; R5II fixated to a random point behind the vase and just did not let go unless I switched off subject detection completely.
I recreated this experiment with Z8, but it had no issues. I retried with R5II, but same again. So after 10 shots, Nikon had 10/10 nailed focuses, Canon 0/10.
The point here is that machines are still not at human level of facial recognition. More sensitive face detection will pick up more faces, but also sometimes random objects.
Canon admits this in the user manual explicitly, and implicitly by including all those additional AF areas with a padlock icon (indicating no subject detection). Again, I’m not sure why you need additional AF area modes when you can just switch off subject detection, but there it is.
So the question here was — how did Canon balance this in practice? How often would I get false positives in a realistic shooting scenario?
From years of working with Z8, I can’t remember a single time it picked up an object. It did miss people with their backs turned or wearing weird novelty sunglasses, but never a reasonably sized face in the frame. On the other hand, Fuji X100VI was even more sensitive than R5II and had even more false positives.
Where exactly did Canon fall on this spectrum? Only a proper field test could tell me.
I’ll compress 11 hours of continuous shooting into a few sentences. In a realistic wedding scenario, neither R5II or Z8 had let me down. There were minor blips and we can analyze them, but for 99% of the time both cameras performed subject detection flawlessly.
The interesting thing was that Canon’s oversensitivity was not really showing up in reality, neither positive or negative. I couldn’t really find cases where it picked up a small face and Nikon didn’t, and there was just one obvious false positive. (R5II found a face on a tattooed hand. Z8 did not. Photo below.)




There was one time where Canon didn’t detect groom’s face and Nikon did (at the time, I had 35mm on R5II and 28mm on Z8). (Photo above right.)
Final issue I had was maid of honor standing behind the bride, where both cameras fixated on the maid of honor and I couldn’t get them to recognize the bride (who was closer to me) until I changed the shooting angle slightly.
When the night fell and disco lights were turned on, nothing special happened — both cameras focused great!
EYE DETECTION
Now if you’ll allow me a small rant: I don’t really get camera settings which allow you to pick left or right eye detection preference. What is that all about?
Unless we’re talking about very predictable circumstances (e.g. in studio), how would I know or be able to decide in advance whether I prefer left or right eye in focus?
I’m not saying it’s not important; I’m saying it’s unpredictable!
You don’t know in advance how people will be turned when shooting them. A far more useful setting would be closer/farther eye preference.
PRIORITY FACES
Finally, R5 Mark II has priority facial recognition. Idea is to identify subjects (and sort them by order of importance) so the camera knows who it should focus on first if multiple faces are detected nearby.
I wanted to try it but camera always refused when loading photo from a card, saying no compatible photos were found. My guess is that it requires JPEGs instead of raw files, but I didn’t bother further with it because I want to be the once deciding who is in focus anyway.
Yes, the bride (for e.g.) may be most important, but after I took 20 photos of her, I’ll want to focus on other people even if she’s close to them. Even if this function works perfectly, if she’s in frame she may pull away focus from other people, which would necessitate turning off this function and remembering to turn it back on later.
It’s just more extra work and I’m not sure it would be worth it. Perhaps in some very different shooting scenario?

FOCUS TRACKING
Let’s talk about subject tracking (Canon) and 3D tracking (Nikon).
Z8 does a good job, but not so good that I’d use this tracking in all scenarios. It’s very good at tracking visible faces, but for objects, especially in low-contrast situations, it quickly falls apart.
Canon is better at tracking objects, but even the R5II will have issues when the object isn’t distinct enough from the surroundings.
However, the tracking is structured very differently: Canon tries to track an object, while Nikon tries to track a small point on an object. (Point is much smaller than the default AF area.)
Issues can arise when Canon misinterprets your intentions and tracks the wrong object.
Quick Case Study
As an example, I tried tracking a brightly colored green watch (small object) immediately next to a larger dark-blue bag on a wooden surface. There was plenty of color contrast, so both cameras should have had an easy job.
And they did. But Canon decided it will track the whole bag, while I wanted to track just the watch next to the bag. No matter what I tried or how much I varied the angle, Canon was sticking to the bag and ignoring the watch.
I changed the scene and placed a black camera near those items. Canon here did allow me to choose whether I want to track the bag or the camera (watch was again ignored). However, this time the camera wasn’t tracked as a whole, but as a part (about 30% of the back of the camera).
Nikon allows (requires) you to set a small focus point on something and will then try to track only that small part. This offers high precision, if it works.
In this scenario, I could easily initiate AF over the watch and it kept tracking it without issues, surely helped by the high contrast of the scene.


Difference in approach (tracking a small point vs. tracking whole object) could explain why Canon is generally better at tracking. It has a larger surface area than a small point and even if you change the shooting angle, its appearance will probably change less than a small section under the point.
On the other hand, this causes two problems. First, it can pick a completely wrong object, like in my initial test.
Secondly, it makes it much less precise when working with shallow DOF, so it can focus on the wrong part of the object which is very frustrating. (Like in example when tracking a black camera.)
Nikon’s tracking of a small point gives it just a small sample so it can lose it more easily in lower contrast situations.
There is again a balance to be struck here and the two manufacturers chose very different paths.
What you prefer depends on your use case. Are you tracking something on a clean background and with deep DOF (Canon wins), or trying to pick just one object in a cluttered environment (Nikon prevails)?
Honestly, neither implementation at this point gives me confidence to rely on it in the field. It’s too hit-and-miss, just too unpredictable and unreliable in high stakes situations.
Tracking people is an order of magnitude better on both cameras as it works in conjunction with face detection, so it’s a whole different story — both cameras excel at it with isolated people. I can’t really pick a winner without months of testing in crowded settings.
TRACKING MECHANISM
Another important difference is in the user-experience. Canon’s tracking is automatic — when the object is detected, it remains detected until you end tracking (e.g. via OK button). It will focus only when you initiate focus, but tracking happens no matter what. Even if focus is lost, the object-frame will be around your object (unless it gets too blurry).
Nikon works differently. It shows you a focus point which you move where you want, and only when you initiate AF will the point stick to an object, start tracking it and keep it in focus. As soon as you let go of your AF button, tracking stops and the AF starting point returns where it was before it began the last tracking session.
This means tracking is less sticky, but if it goes wrong, it’s easier to stop and re-initiate with Nikon — all you need is the shutter button. If the tracking is reliable, Canon’s approach makes for a more relaxed experience.

EYE CONTROL
Eye control should not to be confused with eye detection AF. Former uses photographer’s eye for targeting the AF area, while the latter recognizes eye on a face and focuses the lens on the detected eye.
This is a standout feature I wanted to try ever since I read about it in a leaflet about fancy Canon APS cameras about 30 years ago. I didn’t know how it performed then, but I was happy to try it now.
Note: I don’t wear glasses or contact lenses. If you do, it may influence system’s performance according to Canon user’s guide.
Eye control learns your eye movements and uses it to help target the AF area wherever you’re currently looking in the EVF (it doesn’t work with LCD screen). First step is therefore to train it, which takes around a minute for initial pass.
There are multiple training slots for multiple users of the camera, or for different cases (like with/without glasses or contacts).
On paper, this is a dream feature, at least for me. In reality, things are more complex, as they usually are.
First, one issue I didn’t foresee: I don’t necessarily look at my target at all times while shooting. Sometimes I’ll move my eye to see other parts of the frame to check framing, reduce distractions, avoid or wait for people entering the frame etc.
While this doesn’t last long, it will move the eye target away from desired spot and you can’t initiate AF before you return to the target.
This isn’t Canon’s issue, it’s how we see: little saccades all over the frame. But, it constrains what you’re allowed to look at in the moment of initiating AF, which means you need to learn to look differently. No system upgrade will be able to help with this human characteristic.
Secondly, eye control is quite dependent on the conditions. Whether you’re indoors on outdoors, in dark or light, sunny or overcast, under artificial or natural lighting etc. will significantly influence how it works.
Canon recommends recalibration each time you change anything. This is really good advice, because it transforms the eye control from being an useless curiosity to a pretty useful tool.
How does it work?
Eye control doesn’t move the AF area directly. Instead, it moves something I’ll call eye target (an orange circle with a dot inside, easily distinguishable from rectangular AF area).
It tracks the eye and moves the target constantly (while eye control is on), so at each moment you’ll know where the camera thinks you’re looking. This is informative, as you won’t be surprised at any point, but it’s also sometimes slightly distracting.
Once you’re ready, initiating AF will instantly move the AF area over the eye control target. If you don’t like where AF area fell, you need look elsewhere to re-initiate AF, or use your joystick to correct (without stopping AF).

What is it like in practice?
Freshly calibrated with my naked eye, it works well. It is simply amazing when you suddenly need to move your AF area from one side of the frame to the other; nothing else can match it because it’s not only fast, it’s pretty precise (compared to finger sliding over LCD, or joystick set to high speed).
When used with face detection and people who are reasonably far apart, it also works great. Even if you slightly miss a person, face detection will usually pick them up if you’re in the ball-park.
When you want to focus on objects, that’s when precision really matters and that’s when eye control is less than stellar. I did use it occasionally to give it a proper test, but in the end I couldn’t risk using it often.
Interesting thing is that when it’s wrong, it’s very consistently wrong. If you look at the same object twice it will always bring the target to the same spot. Looking again will produce the same result.
While you can use eye control to come near a target and then just correct the position with your joystick, this doesn’t come naturally. It kind of feels like playing a game of targeting, so your instinct is to continue using your eye to fine tune the position (which usually doesn’t work the second time if it didn’t work the first time) instead of just forgetting about that and using the joystick. I’m guessing a lot of practice would help.
To quantify how well it works: after about 10 calibrations in different conditions, if the last calibration was very recent, my average hit-rate was about 80% for precise focus. (This is average of everything: people and objects, close together and further apart, in changing light conditions, near and far from the camera).
So, to reiterate: you will need to recalibrate often. It takes a minute once you’ve gotten used to it, but you still have to do it if you want high precision. (Canon also claims that calibration learns with time, so it’s possible you’ll have to do it less often over time.)
If it’s a run and gun situation, you may need to turn it off until you’ve had time to recalibrate it. This is simple as you can set up direct custom button shortcut, so it only needs a quick tap and it’s off if it starts misbehaving.
Even though I ended up not using it much, I commend Canon for giving it a proper try. As with any technology, it may be less reliable in the beginning, but as it matures it can become truly useful. (Just remember how bad AF was on first mirrorless cameras!)
I’m hoping that within two generations this might become a reliable and useful tool, perhaps paired with object detection.
Final verdict: useful in some situations, but not for critical work in its current form.

General Photography
EVF
On paper Canon’s EVF is superior: 5,8 million pixels vs. Nikon’s 3,7 million. But it turns out that it matters a great deal what you do with those pixels.
To my eye, Canon’s EVF was slightly less saturated. Turning on OVF simulation didn’t fix this much. This isn’t a huge deal as it matters much more what you actually capture, but it’s worth mentioning.
What is a bigger deal is using the EVF in 1.6x crop mode.
Canon’s live view display in crop mode is abysmal, to the point that in some scenarios I was wondering whether my lens was misfocused. Taking the shot and zooming in showed focus was just fine, so I looked into it further.
It appears that R5II is using some kind of line-skipping when reading the sensor which causes aliasing artefacts (especially visible in diagonal geometry in the photo) and also some general blurriness which caused me to wonder if AF was working properly. (This is true even in non-crop mode, but it’s much less noticeable.)
This is a big deal because I want to know if the lens got the focus right before triggering the shutter, which I can often tell to a useful degree just looking through the Z8’s EVF. This way I just can’t be sure.
My guess here is that this is caused either by R5II sensor’s slower readout speed, and/or energy saving approach, which brings me to the next topic…
BATTERIES & CHARGERS
Battery life on paper gives a huge potential advantage to Canon. CIPA rating gives R5II 250 (EVF) or 540 (LCD) photos on average, while on Z8 it’s 330/340 (EVF/LCD).
Again, the advantage is theoretical because if you use mostly EVF the battery life will be significantly worse on Canon, and this huge inconsistency slightly bothers me. Still, it’s good to have the option of saving batteries using LCD if it gets critical in the field.
On the topic of batteries, let’s mention the chargers. Nikon’s charger has a lengthy wire, while Canon’s needs to be plugged in directly into an outlet. It can be difficult to fit next to other devices.
For example, on a 5-plug extension cord, I can plug in 5 Nikon chargers but only 3 Canon’s. If you need to charge in the field in unpredictable conditions, like negotiating with a DJ/band for one outlet, this flexibility can be important.

FAN
One thing that confused me was hearing a faint whirring sound from R5II while setting it up. It turned out to be the an internal fan, but what I couldn’t grasp was why it was on? Camera was barely turned on for a few minutes without shooting a single photo, just digging through the menus in a room of 21C/70F.
Why would it need to turn on the fan in those conditions?
PAINTWORK
One almost irrelevant detail — R5II has wide painted metal strap eyelets, while Z8’s are chromed and O-shaped. If using the original strap (which on Nikon has additional metal triangles), this doesn’t matter and is probably slightly to Canon’s advantage (as the strap is silently attached to the camera).
However, if you’re using 3rd party attachments which use metal rings (like HoldFast Money Maker and similar), they will strip off the paint from the eyelets within minutes of installing them.
COLORS
Okay, now let’s start an internet war and talk about the default look of SOOC raw photos, or rather about JPEG previews embedded in the raw files (used by camera for image review and some apps like Photo Mechanic).
We prefer Nikon’s, and by a large margin (photo below). They are slightly warmer, less green when using flash at night, more contrasty and a bit more saturated. They look slightly processed in a good way.
Yes, Canon has more natural skin tones in this particular example, but the whole photo looks… cheap?


In the grand scheme of things it (almost) doesn’t matter when you shoot raw because it’s all infinitely adjustable later.
But, there are two cases where it does matter: when you need to keep your inspiration going in the field, and when you need to show your client a raw photo.
Canon’s SooC raws are flat and look like they were taken by a phone in comparison to Nikon’s. During the test shoot, I just couldn’t bring myself to show our clients Canon’s photos and I felt less good about those photos myself, despite knowing it’s irrelevant as I’ll process them later into whatever I desire.
Maybe it sounds more dramatic than it is and it’s probably fixable via custom picture settings anyway, but I preferred the less work of default Nikon look.
Just to confirm, I easily post-processed photos from both cameras to the exact same look and tonality later. They were indistinguishable from each other and I didn’t need to put a lot of effort into it.
EXPOSURE & METERING
Exposure compensation in semi-auto modes like Av/Tv matters less and less as mirrorless cameras get better at evaluative metering, but I’ll mention that Z8 offers +/-5 EV range, while R5II offers +/-3 EV.
Well, I say it matters less and less, but R5II actually had a nasty surprise in store. With Z8, I got very used to the meter’s ability to bias the exposure towards a detected face. It works great when turned on, and while it often burns out the background when shooting against the light, at least I have an option (and I use it).
R5II was confusing here. It has an option mysteriously named Detect priority AE while AF, which I learned was exposure bias towards a detected subject. Z8 shows a big and obvious difference when shooting a subject against a light source, between 1 and 3 EVs depending on the size of the face in the frame. I expected to see the same with R5II.
However, this option on Canon makes no difference, either turned on or off. (See photos below.)




⇡ R5II raw photos; detect priority AE turned on, exp. comp at 0.
With or without subject detection exposure bias, the R5II was leaning heavily towards saving the highlights. And it’s true, this is 100% correct approach… in theory.
Why?
Both sensors have a large dynamic range and Sony sensors (inside Nikon) have lost their advantage to Canon. Both sensors are, for all intents and purposes, ISO-invariant.
Great, so let’s save the highlights and bring up the shadows in post, shall we?
Not so fast.
When shooting in the field without a chance of a do-over later, I need to know what I’m focusing on, I need to know if I focused correctly and I need to know whether I got the shot (e.g. whether the subject blinked, talked, made a grimace…).
Doing ETTR exposure and deliberately allowing shadows to remain dark, when shooting against a light source you often won’t be able to see any of those things! While it’s good to keep the highlights if you need them later, I prefer to do this in those rare occasions via exposure compensation or highlight exposure bias metering shortcut.
The problem was so bad with Canon that in two occasions I literally couldn’t tell what or who I was focusing on when shooting against bright windows. It was just guesswork because the moment was such that I had no time for exposure compensation, so I was shooting essentially blind. I snapped a burst of photos and hoped for the best!

FV MODE
I liked the Fv (flexible value) mode in Canon, which is reminiscent of dedicated dial controlled cameras like ancient Canon A-1 or newer Fuji cameras. It allows you to control any combination of parameters from the exposure triangle flexibly (manual or auto), hence the name.
In theory this is very useful because it’s… well, flexible. But the devil is in the details.
Unless there’s a setting I missed, to control each of the three parameters you don’t get to use the three control wheels, which I’d expect.
You get to use only two wheels: one to select parameter, and the other to set it. The third wheel stays unused.
To be fair, usefulness of this depends on how often you need to switch between auto and manual setting of each parameter, and there is the fourth possible parameter (exposure compensation), but I still can’t get away from the feeling they could have thought this through better. Am I missing something?
IMAGE REVIEW
When talking about reviewing the photos, a tiny irritation I have with R5II is that it displays a message MODE / Movie <—> Stills Switching every time you press playback button after camera was previously off. There is no way to turn off the message and while initially useful, I’d prefer not to look at it for the rest of R5’s lifespan.
The function itself is actually useful — it tells you that by pressing the mode button you can switch between looking at photos or movies separately; useful if you’re a hybrid shooter. I know of no quick way to do this on Nikon, only through filters.
DOF PREVIEW
Let’s talk about shooting a bit more.
Canon always displays live view with wide open aperture, unless you press DOF preview button (which I always remap to something more useful). Nikon has the a14 custom setting which lets you choose, and also allows to assign DOF preview to a custom button.

AUTO-ISO
My (and apparently, internet’s) final grievance here is the auto-ISO.
I use auto-ISO 99% of the time, which means I prefer it on. However, R5II allows you to change it between auto-ISO and manual ISO by a simple turn of a wheel (thumb wheel by default).
I accidentally turned off auto-ISO a few times without realizing it by touching the wheel during the shoot. When this happened at night, since I only touched it slightly, ISO went from auto to 100 so I had plenty of blurry shots. Only the sound of dragging the shutter made me realize what was happening.
This is only part of the trouble: returning to the auto setting isn’t straightforward. If the metering timer is active (and it usually is when you’re panicking), you can’t return to auto-ISO the way you turned it off. You can do it either when the metering timer expires, or using the touchscreen.
This one is a real head-scratcher. Internet seems to think so as well, so I’d venture a guess that I’m not missing anything.
Further exacerbating the confusion: if you measured a scene and you accidentally turn the wheel, now the ISO will move relative to the measured ISO. But after the timer expires, ISO will return to auto. So sometimes you realize you accidentally moved ISO and start solving a problem which will disappear in a few seconds.
And yes, you can lock this wheel, but that brings us back to the whole off-lock-on story. Better solution in my case would be to remap the ISO-setting to another wheel (like main control dial) which I can hardly imagine being accidentally activated.
For comparison, Z8 has a dedicated ISO-button. While depressed, one wheel will switch between auto/manual ISO, while the other will set the ISO (either manual value or lowest allowed value in auto-mode). This is straightforward, logical and it’s practically impossible to do it by accident. (Of course, if you regularly shoot using manual ISO, you may like Canon’s approach better.)

Sensor & Shutter
Both cameras have 45MP backside illuminated stacked sensors.
Quick explainer for those who need it: backside illuminated means better light gathering efficiency (less noise); stacked means quicker readout (allowing for good electronic shutter, quicker AF, less rolling shutter, higher resolution video).
Let’s get this out of the way first: it’s becoming popular to say that 50MP sensors are uselessly large and that 25MP was enough. I disagree. It very much depends on what you’re shooting and what you intend to do with it.
Yes, the file size is large, buffer and storage get filled quicker, pixels are smaller and noisier… but, for my shooting style, this size of sensor is practically ideal!
I shoot prime lenses, so I very much enjoy flexibility of instantly getting a 1.5-1.6x focal length at the push of a button and still having enough resolution to deliver in high-res to a client — and all without having to use a zoom lens with added weight, price and slower aperture.

SHUTTER
Shutter. Canon has it, Nikon doesn’t. Both cameras support fully silent, blackout-free electronic shutter (ES), but Canon kept the mechanical shutter (MS) as well.
At first, this confused me. Why would you want an expensive and breakable mechanical shutter that will limit your exposure speed and burst speed, produce sound and invite attention, if you have a sensor that’s good enough to shoot electronically?
My own testing showed that the dynamic range of R5II’s sensor is close enough in both MS and ES modes that it probably doesn’t matter much in practice. So what’s the issue?
In short, Canon’s own sensor in R5 Mark II still lags considerably behind Z8’s (designed by Nikon, manufactured by Sony) in one important aspect: readout speed.
R5II readout speed is roughly 1/160s, while Z8 zooms around in comparison, close to 1/270s.
Often this slower speed won’t matter, but there will be cases which warrant inclusion of complexities that come along with a mechanical shutter. Examples are limited flash sync speed, more pronounced banding under certain types of lighting and perhaps most importantly — rolling shutter in photography.
Canon (rightly) didn’t want to risk all that and gave us the option of using either MS or ES.
Now, I’m a big fan of pure ES. If it was a global shutter, there would be no end to my joy, but regardless, Z8 has never caused me an issue in practice due to its ES-only design.
Reason I like it so much is that it’s completely silent and unbreakable. When shooting events and people with relatively short lenses (24mm to 58mm are my personal preference), shooting without disturbing anyone and constantly reminding them they’re under your lens means a huge deal for the candid approach.
It’s good that Canon joined this party, even if it’s lagging a bit behind at the moment.
However, here we arrive to a problem: I got spoiled and got used to shooting wide open apertures even under unreasonably bright conditions (e.g. f/1.4 at 1/32000s). I used Canon similarly in MS mode, only to find overexposed photos. My bad.

I should have turned on safety shift, but surely I can use MS+ES combination to preserve wide open aperture automatically? (Like on 10 year old Fuji cameras.)
Well… no. I found no option to allow this.
Closest workaround would be to map ES to a custom shooting mode and use a shortcut to activate it, but that still requires you to be mindful of shooting conditions, which is the exact opposite of what I want to do in my job (I want to focus on events, moments and building connection to my clients during the shoot, instead of minding technical details of the camera).
I’m not sure why Canon didn’t offer an ES+MS option like Fuji, even if it had drawbacks (like not realizing which mode it will use before triggering the shutter unless you pay close attention to measured shutter speed).
With that said, if there needs to be a shutter sound, I very much like Canon’s. It’s well dampened, pretty discreet and quite pleasant in a way.
Finally, flash sync speeds are close. Canon can do 1/250s with MS, 1/160s with ES. Nikon does 1/250s with 1/200s fallback option (before switching to HSS mode) because some 3rd party remote triggers have a slight delay which will cause enough of a mismatch that you’ll notice a narrow black band in the photo (since we’re on the edge of what the sensor is capable of).

DYNAMIC RANGE
Let’s skim the surface on the dynamic range, another topic where I’ve read countless articles claiming that it’s just not important anymore. Again, strongly disagree.
One of my regular island ceremony venues (shown in photos throughout this article) always requires me to shoot against the light while the people have spotty sun rays hitting them randomly. (Using flash would be distracting and difficult to justify to clients.)
Such wide dynamic range in the scene is at the very limits of what D850 and Z8 sensors can handle and even 1-stop narrower dynamic range would start to be an issue. Burning out the background is one thing, but since people have spotty sun rays hitting them, I can’t burn out their faces to save those in the shadows.
So, Canon has been catching up with dynamic range through the last decade and I can say it finally caught up! Its sensor is now on par with Z8’s and also ISO-invariant.
I was glad to see this, honestly, because the reason I first left Canon in the era of 5D Mark III was it’s abysmal dynamic range which could barely handle +1.5EV lift of its raw files. I distinctly remember buying a small and light travel camera for our family (Fuji 100T), lifting its raw +4EV out of curiosity and being flabbergasted by the results! (I fully switched to Fuji within a month.)
Anyway, both cameras are now really close. When doing a +5EV lift of their files in contrasty conditions at base ISO (64 in Z8, 100 in R5II in MS mode), results were really, really close.
To my eye, noise in shadows was reasonable with a slight edge going to Canon in high-frequency noise. However, it had more very low-frequency noise (blotches of color) which is difficult to remove. I also noticed a slight magenta cast in the shadows sometimes.
Nothing dramatic, but since I was pixel-peeping, here it is.
When switching to ES with R5II, the noise was slightly worse, but again, nothing you’d probably notice without looking for it.
PRICE
Canon EOS R5 Mark II is more expensive. Numbers will quickly become irrelevant, but R5II was roughly $3900 and Nikon Z8 was $3400 at the time of writing this. (Let’s not even go into how much they cost in Europe!)
If I was to guess, I’d say that the mechanical shutter mechanism and eye control sensors account for a good portion of this difference, but R5II is also a more recent arrival to the market, hence commanding a higher price (for a while).

Conclusion
I did my best to be objective throughout this review, but in the end, when trying to make a conclusion and pick a camera, what you do and how you do it will necessarily color your decision.
For my candid, documentary event reportage approach, both cameras are super-capable and pretty enjoyable to work with and they have practically identical image quality.
What it will ultimately come down will be, first, any outright dealbreakers, and secondly, nuances of how each camera works, especially in the area of customization and ergonomics.
Your mileage will vary, so I hope I gave enough breadth and information that you can make a well-informed decision.

CONS
Since we cleared the air and admitted that this conclusion is necessarily subjective, I can say that there is one big issue which I just can’t possibly get over — the R5II’s flip-out LCD.
It’s just deeply incompatible with the way I work and is a breakage waiting to happen the way I use my cameras.
It’s slightly ironic, because not so long ago we were shooting DSLRs where shooting on the LCD was wishful thinking: slow and impractical.
LCD was often fixed with excruciatingly slow contrast-detect AF, practical only for stationary objects. OVF was alpha and omega, so the majority of discussion was around number of cross-type AF points and what their viewfinder coverage was.
Now we’re spoilt in comparison: 90%+ AF coverage with hundreds (or thousands) of AF points grouped into AF areas, fast refresh of both LCD and EVF, subject recognition and tracking, great low light performance… but we’re unhappy with how LCD tilts or flips out! But such are the times.
I also have objections to the way R5II tends to track objects it somewhat arbitrarily chooses. Switching AF modes is slower than on Z8, which counts in the heat of the moment. I find R5II’s joystick slightly less predictable and somewhat poorly placed.
Its smaller body lacks a few buttons compared to Z8. This is important because fewer customizable buttons mean fewer quick ways to control the camera, adapt it to your needs and fix the ways camera is incompatible with the way you work.
On R5II auto-ISO can be accidentally turned off and slow to turn back on.
Main control wheel is also awkwardly placed behind the shutter button and the menu button is inconveniently placed on the opposite side of the camera if you want single-handed use. Its keys are not illuminated and the top LCD illumination-button is small and difficult to find in the dark.
R5II also doesn’t allow 1EV-step aperture adjustments. Structure of custom My Menus is more rigid but more compartmentalized.
The fact it exhausts the battery two times faster when using EVF compared to LCD makes it less predictable and the charger is impossible to plug into a tight spot.

PROS
On the plus side, camera is even more customizable than the Z8.
It’s significantly lighter and better suited to smaller hands.
It has a hardware lock switch if you need it, along with an extra control wheel (for a total of three) — one of which is ideally placed under your thumb and makes quick scrolling a breeze.
Once you get used to menu navigation with three control wheels, it’s quicker than Z8’s.
Subject tracking and face detection in extremely low light is better, probably due to its dual-pixel sensor structure.
Face detection is slightly better than on Z8, although carrying risks of false positives. Setting up face priorities can imaginably make your life easier in certain scenarios.
Eye control is a unique and interesting addition. Depending on your shooting style and needs, you may find it useful even in its current form.
And, if you stick to LCD only, it will significantly outlast Z8’s battery.

VERDICT?
So finally, is Canon R5 Mark II the camera that will make me switch systems?
Not in this iteration.
Let’s see what Mark III brings and if it changes the game as original 5D Mark III did.
Thanks for reading!
(Go here for videography focused review of R5 Mark II.)





